Home Latest News Analysis Sixth place or ninth with the FA Cup? Tottenham need to decide...

Sixth place or ninth with the FA Cup? Tottenham need to decide what success looks like under De Zerbi

De Zerbi

Would finishing sixth be a success for Tottenham this season? It would be a big step forward, but if Spurs want to be judged as a club going places again, sixth should be treated as progress, not the finish line.

It is a question worth settling now, before the season starts telling its own story. Roberto De Zerbi took his side into the international break 11th, with 12 points from ten games, after a 1-0 defeat at Leeds United ended a run of three straight league wins. Everton were sixth at the break on 16 points, so the gap to that line is four points, one good week.

Where you stand on sixth depends on which yardstick you pick up: the last two seasons, or the money spent last summer.

Why sixth would feel like a huge jump

Start with where this club has come from. Tottenham finished 17th in back-to-back seasons, and last May they only stayed up with a 1-0 win over Everton on the final day. Three managers came and went in that campaign, and De Zerbi only arrived in March to drag them over the line.

This season did not start much better. Spurs were winless and bottom after six games, with a squad full of new faces still learning each other. To go from that to sixth, in one season, would be a climb of 11 places from where they finished in May.

That is why plenty of fans would happily call it a success. Progress is improvement, and an 11-place jump with European football back on the table is about as clear an improvement as you get.

What did Tottenham actually set out to do?

Here is the catch. Success is usually measured against the target, and nobody at the club has been talking about sixth.

Spurs spent almost £400million in the summer. Vinai Venkatesham has also been very clear about where he wants the bar, saying on The Sports Agents podcast: “If you work for Tottenham, when we talk about being here to win, that means we’re here to win the Premier League. That’s what this football club wants to do.” As we covered when the chief executive admitted Spurs had drawn up a relegation plan, he wants the club consistent in the Champions League too.

Nobody sensible expects that this season. But you don’t spend that kind of money to aim for the Europa League places. The question the club would have asked itself in the summer was what it takes to get back into the Champions League, not what it takes to scrape into Europe. Whether that was realistic is another matter.

Objective met, or a stepping stone?

There is a fair counter-argument. If the real remit for year one of a rebuild was simply to get Tottenham back into European football, and they hit it, then by definition they have succeeded. Meeting your objective is what success means.

We just don’t think that was the objective. Sixth is a stepping stone on the road to where Spurs want to be. A stepping stone is a good thing to stand on, but you don’t throw a parade for it.

Sixth place or ninth with the FA Cup?

Try this test. Would you rather finish sixth, or ninth and win the FA Cup?

Almost every Spurs fan picks the cup, and that tells you everything. The FA Cup winner also gets a Europa League place, so the trophy gives you the same reward as a strong league finish, plus a day nobody forgets. Spurs fans know that better than most after the Europa League win, the parade and the feeling it left around the club.

Look at Oliver Glasner at Crystal Palace. He did push Palace up the table, but what people remember is the trophy he won there. That is what success looks like to most supporters: something you can lift, not a number in a table.

So by that logic, De Zerbi could finish outside the top six this season and still have a better claim to a successful year than if he finishes sixth with nothing in the cabinet.

The Arsenal comparison

It helps to look at how a rebuild across north London was judged. In the seasons Arsenal went into saying they wanted the title and finished second, nobody called those failures. They were positive seasons. But few would call them a success either, because the target was the league and they did not win it.

The same language fits Spurs. Sixth would be positive. It would show the project is moving. It just would not be success in the full sense, because the club has told us its ambition is much bigger than that.

And what would seventh or eighth mean?

Our guess is the club would see seventh or eighth as disappointing, but would still point to the climb from 17th as proof of progress. Sixth with Europe secured would be sold as a good season. A Champions League place would be an unbelievable one. That feels like the honest scale, and it lines up with our view when we asked whether Tottenham can climb from 11th into the Champions League places: top seven is the floor, top five is the target.

Why the bar matters for De Zerbi

This is not just an argument for the pub. Where the bar sits decides how patient people are with the manager when the bad weeks come. De Zerbi was named Manager of the Month for October, and he has already said his team are “not good enough yet” to look beyond the next game. That is the right tone for a squad that has changed this much.

Spurs also have no European football to juggle this season, which gives De Zerbi a full week on the training pitch before almost every league game. That is an advantage the clubs around them don’t have, and it is one more reason to aim higher than sixth.

The run is kind on paper too. Ipswich, Sunderland, Fulham and Hull City all come in the next five league games, as we set out in our Tottenham vs Ipswich Town preview. If Spurs are serious about more than sixth, this is the stretch where they have to start acting like it.

Verdict: sixth is progress, a trophy is success

If Tottenham finish sixth, we will not complain, and nobody else should either. After two 17th-place finishes and a relegation plan sitting in a drawer, it would be a genuinely good season and proof the rebuild is heading the right way.

But it should be called what it is: progress. Success at a club spending close to £400million in one summer means a trophy or a Champions League place. Anything less is a step on the way, and Spurs only get to call it a success if they kick on from it next season.