Thomas Frank takes charge of his first game as Crystal Palace manager at Coventry City on Saturday, and for Spurs fans it is the start of a test that should finally settle an argument: was he a bad manager, or just the wrong one for Tottenham?
Frank lasted less than eight months in N17. He was sacked in February with Spurs 16th and only five points above the relegation zone, and the club survived on the final day under the men who followed him. Now he is at Selhurst Park on a deal until June 2029, with a side that is bottom of the Premier League.
The kick-off at Coventry is 3pm on Saturday, the same time Spurs host Ipswich Town. How the next few months go in south London will tell us a lot about what really went wrong in north London.
Was Thomas Frank the wrong fit at Tottenham?
Our view is yes, and it was obvious from the timing as much as the man. Spurs had just won the Europa League. There was a parade, a feeling around the club and a squad that believed in an attacking way of playing. Whoever came in needed to keep that energy going, and the profile that suited that moment was a big, proven name with an attacking identity.
Frank was neither. He arrived with a brilliant reputation from Brentford, he talked well about high performance and how he wanted to play, and plenty of Spurs fans bought into it. Then very little of what he promised showed up on the pitch. Apart from a handful of good nights early on, it never clicked.
That is why Palace makes sense for him. A club that needs organising, does not live on big signings and is used to a manager shaping the squad around a clear plan is far closer to the job he did at Brentford than anything at Tottenham.
Or was it Brentford that made Frank?
This is the part that should worry Palace fans. Brentford’s model has always been about the structure around the manager: the recruitment, the data and the way they replace people before they leave. The results since Frank left suggest that machine still works without him.
Under Keith Andrews, Brentford are eighth after ten games, with three wins, five draws and only two defeats for 14 points. That is two points more than De Zerbi’s Spurs, who went into the break 11th on 12 points after the defeat at Elland Road.
Frank did a remarkable job there. He took them up through the 2020-21 play-offs and kept them in the top flight with finishes of 13th, 9th and 16th before a top-half finish in 2024-25. But Brentford rarely looked like a European side under him, and the step forward without him raises a fair question about how much of that success was the system rather than the coach.
The job waiting at Selhurst Park
There is no easing in. Palace are bottom with seven points, two from safety, after Pierre Sage was dismissed on 12 November following a seventh league defeat of the season. Coventry, managed by Frank Lampard, are the first test, and the run after that includes Real Sociedad in the Europa League, Hull City at home and a trip to Chelsea.
As we covered when Frank took a pay cut to save Crystal Palace, his contract is built around staying up. If he does it, he earns back close to his Spurs salary without the Spurs expectations.
What it would mean for Tottenham
If Frank keeps Palace up and has them comfortable by spring, the verdict on his Spurs spell becomes simple: the appointment was wrong, not the coach. Tottenham’s process picked the wrong man for the moment, and that is a lesson about how the club chooses managers, not just about Frank.
If Palace keep sinking, the harder conclusion follows. It would suggest Brentford’s structure did more of the heavy lifting than anyone at Spurs realised when they hired him.
Either way, Spurs have moved on. De Zerbi was named Manager of the Month for October and gets players back for Ipswich, as we set out in our Tottenham vs Ipswich Town preview. But the scoring problem we flagged in ten goals in ten games is a reminder that the rebuild after Frank is still a work in progress.
Our verdict: Frank will keep Palace up
We think Frank keeps Palace up. Not by much, and probably somewhere around the lower end of mid-table rather than anything Oliver Glasner managed there, but this is the kind of job he is built for.
And if he does, Spurs fans should be honest about it. Frank was not a fraud. He was the wrong appointment at the worst possible time, straight after a trophy, at a club that needed a big name to keep the momentum going. Palace will not ask him to be that, and that is exactly why he could succeed there.















