Tottenham are looking at right-backs from Palmeiras to Villarreal as Pedro Porro’s future drifts towards Spain, but the best answer to the problem might already be in the squad: Archie Gray.
Gray is 20, an England Under-21 international and, for now, mostly a midfielder at Spurs. Yet the last time Tottenham needed a right-back in a Premier League game, at Elland Road, it was Gray who dropped in there. And with four senior central midfielders ahead of him, right-back looks like the place where he can actually get a run of games.
So is Archie Gray more useful to Tottenham at right-back than in midfield? We think he is, and Porro’s situation makes the question more urgent than it was a month ago.
Why is right-back suddenly a problem for Spurs?
Porro is the reason. The World Cup winner signed a new contract until 2031 in June, but he has made only four Premier League starts this season because of fitness and injury problems, and he has spent much of the autumn talking about a return to Spain. As we reported, Porro has decided to leave Tottenham, and he sees Barcelona as a better fit than Real Madrid.
Spurs have reacted the way clubs usually do: by drawing up a list. Palmeiras’ Agustín Giay, now on a new deal to 2031 with a price above €20m, is on it, and so is Villarreal’s Alexander Freeman, who we profiled in our Alexander Freeman scouting report.
Both make sense. But before Tottenham spend upwards of €20m on a new right-back, they should be sure the player they want isn’t already training at Hotspur Way.
What happened when Gray played right-back at Leeds?
Gray started at Elland Road in a midfield three with Sandro Tonali and Mateus Fernandes. When Roberto De Zerbi made his triple change after 65 minutes, Porro came off for Conor Gallagher and Gray dropped to right-back for the rest of the game.
It wasn’t a game anyone at Spurs will remember fondly, and we were critical of the team sheet in our look at how Tottenham shaped their side around Leeds. But it showed what De Zerbi already knows: when he needs a right-back from his bench, Gray is the one he trusts.
It is also not a new job for him. Gray won the Championship Young Player of the Season award with Leeds United in 2023-24, a season in which he played at right-back as well as in midfield, and that is where a lot of people first saw how good he could be.
Is there room for him in midfield?
This is the honest problem. Spurs spent £185m on Tonali and Fernandes in the summer, and when that pair are fit, they start. Behind them sit Rodrigo Bentancur, Lucas Bergvall and Gallagher, who was Spurs’ liveliest player off the bench at Leeds.
Gray has done well when he has played there. He scored against Crystal Palace, and he wasn’t one of the problems at Elland Road. But there is a big difference between getting minutes and getting the steady run of games a 20-year-old needs to grow into a top midfielder. With five senior central midfielders in the squad, that run is very hard to see coming at Tottenham.
At right-back it is different. Spurs have Porro, who wants to go, and then Gray. That is a much shorter queue.
What does Gray bring that Porro doesn’t?
They are very different full-backs, and that is not a bad thing. Porro is an attacker first: he gets high, he crosses, he shoots, and he can win a game on his own when he is fit and in rhythm.
Gray is a midfielder playing full-back. He is comfortable stepping inside, he can help De Zerbi’s build-up from the back, and he gives Spurs extra security when they lose the ball. For a coach who builds everything through Jan Paul van Hecke and Micky van de Ven, an inverted full-back who can play like a third midfielder is a useful tool, not a compromise.
Will he start against Ipswich?
Probably not. Porro is fit again after his time with Spain, and as long as he is at the club and available, he is De Zerbi’s first choice. Our Tottenham predicted lineup vs Ipswich Town on Saturday has Porro at right-back, with Gray on the bench.
But the bigger picture is the next six months, not the next game. If Porro is going, every minute Gray plays at right-back between now and the summer is a chance to find out whether Spurs really need to buy one.
Verdict: make Archie Gray the right-back in waiting
We would make it official. Gray should be Tottenham’s No.2 right-back for the rest of the season, pushing Porro now and ready to take over if he leaves. That gives him the regular minutes midfield can’t, and it gives Spurs an honest answer before they spend money.
There is a family angle too. Scotland’s new boss Sebastien Pocognoli has said he wants Gray, as we covered when Scotland made their move for Tottenham’s England Under-21 star. A settled role at club level is the best way for him to make that decision on his own terms. If he can make right-back his own at Spurs, both his country and his club will know exactly what kind of player they have.













